38
indonesian team study 1
TOURISM AND PROSTITUTION
1. INTRODUCTION
This working paper
is a report and conclusion of a study which lasted for about four months. From the
various sources which enabled me to make this paper, we expect to clarify the
relations between tourism and prostitution. Therefore we can see that the
problem of women will become the ultimate target of this study.
In explaining the
problem of tourism and its relation to prostitution, there has been a lot of
discussion with people who are connected with this problem. The study was
concentrated in Jakarta, the capital of Indonesia. The choice of this place is
considered reasonable, for Jakarta is the centre of development activities and
also industrial development, but at the same time it is the doorway to tourist
centres throughout the country.
In the first part
of this study we see some aspects of the problem of tourism in Indonesia. Then
we will see the position of women as manpower in the tourist industry.
The second chapter
will discuss the problem of prostitution. We will see the variety of prostitu
39
tion, but with some
conclusions as to why (the cause and background) women involve themselves in
prostitution. We will see also the relation between tourism and
prostitution.
The third part will
explain the problem of women and the basic rights of women. In the last part
there will be a kind of theological reflection on the problem of women and its
relation to the service of the church amidst the national development and
personality building according to human dignity.
The data is quoted
from competent institutions. And some conclusions are taken from discussions with the prostitutes and the keepers
themselves.
The related aspects
of the problem of women and human rights to the development of Indonesia's
cultural pattern and national development will be discussed in part.
The theological reflection at the end of this paper is the final conclusion of the
two participants in this
workshop, after thorough discussion.
2. INDONESIA
AS A COUNTRY OF TOURISM
Indonesia is an
archipelago consisting of more than 3,000 islands, which lie on the equator,
between Asia and Australia and also between the Pacific and Indian Oceans.
Many beautiful
beaches have become tourist objects of the trade, such as Bali (Sanur, Kuta, Legian
and other beaches), Java (Carita, Pelabuhan
Ratu, Pangandaran, Parangtritis and other beaches), Sumatera
(Cermin and other beaches).
Many mountain areas
have become rest and recreation sites, such as Berastagi (North Sumatera), Puncak (West Java), Tawangmangu (Central Java), and so on.
There are also
small islands which have become tourist places, such as - Nias
on the west side of Sumatera, Pulau-Pulau
Seribu (Thousand Islands) on the northern part of
Jakarta, Pulau Kayangan on
the west side of Ujung Pandang
(South Sulawesi), and so on.
Besides that,
Indonesia has a wealth of tourist attraction, such as Sekaten
Fair at Yogyakarta, corpse burning in Bali, corpse
burial in Tana Toraja,
South Sulawesi, Jakarta Fair, and many provincial arts. We can also note some specific tourist at-
40
tractions, such
as Borobudur temple, Jepara
handicraft, and batik.
Economic development
of Indonesia is now actively pursued by the Government, which also has a big
influence on the tourist infrastructural progress. There are no less than 25
international and 7 domestic airways operating in Jakarta.
Inter-city
transportation in Java can be done by train. And there are at least 10 bus
companies which support the tourist industry. Besides, in Jakarta and some
other cities we have also local transportation, such as becaks,
bemos, buses, trains and taxis.
The International
Union of Official Travel
Organization (IUCTO), which later on became World Tourism Organisation (WTO),
attached to the UNO, defines tourism as follows:
(1) People
who travel for pleasure, family affairs, health and so on, either within the
country or travelling abroad.
(2) People
who travel to attend conferences, either within the country or abroad.
(3) People
who travel for business, either for the company management or the company
expansion abroad.
(4) People
who come by tourist cruise.
(5) People
who live in dormitories for study.
From the definition
we can conclude that there are many activities, especially in the cities
related to tourism. In Jakarta, the capital and the biggest city in Indonesia,
according to WTO definition, there are many people coming as tourists, either from abroad or by domestic
travel.
One of the
supporting factors in tourist industrial development, beside some other factors
as mentioned above, is to provide entertainment centres.
In Jakarta, there
are scores of night clubs and discos, steambath and
massage parlours, and some shopping centres. There are also some cultural
centres, such as Taman Miniatur
Indonesia Indah (Beautiful Indonesia in Miniature),
museums and recreational centers as Taman Ria, Ta man Ria Renaja,
and Ancol.
Supporting factors
for the tourist industry opens new
41
opportunities and
new employment schemes. Such employment opportunities are especially widely
open for women.
Many opportunities
demand high or junior level s-kills, such as hotel personnel, airline companies,
and so on. But there are many which just need some special skills for certain
work.
In the survey,
which is done in night clubs, and massage parlours, the labour force does not
have high school diplomas.
In such openings,
women are required to be able to serve their guests according to their skills.
If they are beautiful and courteous, such jobs are always open for them.
At Shanti beauty salon in Menteng
(Jakarta), from its 33 women employees, such as hairdressers, beauticians,
masseurs, only three are high school graduates. There are 11 housewives and 8 widows.
At Ibu Bandung traditional massage parlour, Kebayoran Baru (Jakarta), where
masseurs are about 30 to 40 years of age, of 28 people employed - mostly women
- no one has ever studied in high school.
At Flamingo night
club, Ancol (Jakarta), from its 80 hostesses there
are a few of them who graduated from high schools and one fifth are secondary school graduates.
From the above
mentioned data we can conclude as follows:
(1) Many
work opportunities relating to the tourist industry are provided for women. In
this case, no university education is needed.
(2) The
tendency to look for jobs in the tourist industry faces the applicant with hard
competition, because there is no balance between the number of the labour force
and the existing labour market.
(3) Many
women who are willing to work in the tourist industry are influenced by their
daily needs.
Therefore there is
a tendency to work at the formal jobs but at the same time utilize them to do
prostitution. We will discuss this later in this paper.
42
3. THE
WORLD OF PROSTITUTION
This paper defines
prostitution as physical surrender of a woman to the sexual needs of any male
who desire it on a payment basis.
This definition should
be noted before we see the relation of the problem of women in general and
tourism specifically.
As it happens
everywhere, the people on the prostitution stage are the prostitutes,
customers, keepers, intermediaries or merchants of women. In this paper, we
will deal more widely with the prostitutes themselves and their practice
attached to tourism.
In fact there are two kinds of prostitution. The first one is legal
prostitution, the second one is covered
prostitution.
The legal
prostitution is:
-brothel
prostitutes in certain locations. In Jakarta there are five separate locations,
based on the municipal government policy.
-call girls
(prostitutes), where in practice prostitution goes on by introducing the girl
to the customer in a certain place. In Jakarta, this belongs to high class
prostitution, because the price is very expensive.
-street walkers,
prostitutes who look for customers in public places. Such practices can be
found on the pavement of the streets, where lights are not shining brightly,
such as public recreational places at Jakarta Fair, Jakarta, beside the
bridges, etc.
The covered
prostitution is utilizing other works as
a cover of the prostitutes.
Such practices are
found in entertainment centers in Jakarta.
Many hostesses in
the night clubs function as prostitutes with their customers after working
hours. Many massage girls in steambath and massage
parlours function also as prostitutes. Many score girls in billiard centres can
also be utilized as prostitutes. Many beauticians in beauty salons function as
prostitutes.
Last September the
municipal government of Jakarta Raya closed down
temporarily 16 beauty salons.
43
The reason was,
that they also provided rooms for prostitution,
although they denied it by saying that such rooms were used as massage
rooms.
4. THE
BACKGROUND FOR BECOMING A PROSTITUTE
The following
results from conversations with prostitutes are noted down. They describe how
they became prostitutes:
WARSIH
Native of Central
Java, near Sala. She is now active in the
prostitution complex at Block P, Kebayoran Baru south Jakarta. When she was asked why she became a
prostitute, she answered, "It is better to be a prostitute, than to be
taken to Lampung or Jambi
(transmigration project sites)". More than 100 friends refused to go for
transmigration and chose to become prostitutes. She herself has
"worked" for tour months; she is one of the 300 active prostitutes of
Block P.
MEITY
Native of Manado. She is a prostitute who also functions as a hostess
at Sunset Bar, Taman Impian
Jaya Ancol, north Jakarta.
She never thought
of entering this kind of world. She even angrily called it as dirty thing.
On one Sunday, four
years ago she was raped by her own stepfather. He promised to give her a
motorcycle and had intercourse with her 20 times. But what she got was only
contraceptive pills. This might have happened on and on, had her mother not
caught them in action and immediately sent her away. She could not bear the
shame, because this event was announced to all the relatives and neighbors. And she decided to become a hostess in Jakarta.
She has no more desire to return to Manado. "Never. Even until death".
CORTUM
Native of Karawang, 27, coming from a family of good reputation which
also has a rice field and water buffaloes. White skinned, sharp faced, still
having the beauty of her younger days, but an empty smile. She had even been
married to a man of her parents' choice, but they were not happy. They always
quarrelled, because according to her,
her husband was restricting her very much. But that marriage left 2 children of 9 and 6.
One night she was
upset. She attempted to strangle
44
her husband, while
he was sleeping. She does not know whether he died or survived, but the same night
she fled to Jakarta, met her friend who invited her to become a prostitute. She
accepts this whole heartedly, and she is still doing her job at Bongkaran Tanah Abang, Central Jakarta, where she has worked for five
years.
She lives near the
brothel, without any future plans or ideals.
TUKIYEM
Native of Subang, West Java. Married for five times. She became a
prostitute because of "dombret", a kind of
"trobadour" travelling from place to place
to entertain people during harvest.
At 13 she was sent
by her parents to join that group, with the reason being that she had to
collect money before her marriage. She became a singer and dancer and followed
the travel of such an entertainer. This was a custom in Subang,
Indramayu, Karawang, that
girls are encouraged to earn money before their marriage.
She is now doing
her job at Kramat Tunggak,
North Jakarta, near the harbour. She earns about Rp.
8,000 every night and she works seven days a week. She has a fiancé now and is
planning to get married for the sixth time, when there has been enough
preparation.
5. HOPE
AND FUTURE INSIGHT OF THE PROSTITUTES
There is one
question which each prostitute finds very difficult to answer - either legal
ones or the covered ones, and those who work under hostesses of entertainment
centres.
The question is,
"How long will this work last?" Each time when this question arises
they seem to think seriously and answer carefully. There are those who answer
the simple question. But many of them are quite open to discussing it, involving
in the discussion the meaning, significance and aim of human life, beginning
from this question.
When the discussion
begins with how long they have done this work, they try to cover their answers.
The answers like, "Just for two weeks, Uncle", or "just one
month, Brother" and other kinds of answers show that they recently began
their jobs. Therefore the questioning man will conclude for himself that he is
facing a new "thing" Of course, the
45
price will be
decided after bargaining and it can reach to a higher one.
But when the
question above arises and is discussed together seriously, the prostitute will
see that her future is dark, full of uncertainty. From various serious answers
of how far they can go, will come thoughts on the struggle of humanity.
Someone who has
involved herself in such work tells that it is very difficult to get out of it
and begin a new life or look for a new job. Here we can see that she wants to
leave the world of prostitution, but she does not know how to get out of it.
But there are also
prostitutes who really want to get out of it and they have taken serious steps
through saving their money. They think to stop after they have saved enough
money and then begin a new work.
But there are a
number of prostitutes, both legal and the covered ones, who discuss this
question seriously, and give their answer that they want to leave this work as
soon as possible. But they need some one else to accompany them (her), to look
for a way out, and show the possible and necessary steps.
6. THE
RELATION TO TOURISM
When we relate
prostitution and the development of tourism, it seems that there is an
interdependent relation. Prostitution, legally or covered, is increasing because
of the supra-structure of
tourism which supports the tourist industry.
Development of
tourist supra-structure, such as
hotel facilities and entertainment, night clubs, steambaths,
billiard centres, etc., will become supporting factors for developing prostitution
practices. This statement is also confirmed by some other discussions with some
girls who work in these places.
There is a massage
girl at Jalan Blora,
Central Jakarta, who has some customers from other cities. They come to Jakarta
periodically for business. They always demand an "all in" service.
But she also earns a big amount of money.
46
There is a
prostitute in the locality of Kramat Tunggak, who has many experiences of serving foreigners.
Many of the customers are sailors, whose ships are anchored at the harbor of Tanjung Priuk, not far from the locality. She is proud to serve
them, although they do not speak Indonesian nor
English fluently.
The prostitute can
only say in English, "three thousand rupiah"
or "five thousand rupiah", while showing
her fingers to explain the requested amount. They both can understand that they
are now bargaining. I have seen such actions myself.
Two of these
examples show the interdependent relationship, as mentioned above. The practice
of prostitution will increase especially in big cities, such as Jakarta, where
prostitution is inseparable from the development of the tourist industry.
From this survey
and study, seeing Jakarta as one of the industrial cities in Indonesia, and
therefore also developing the tourist industry, let me note down some
problematic points to be studied:
(1) The
development and expansion of a city, from a non-industrial one towards an
industrial one, cannot avoid the tendency to make tourist attractions.
As it has been
explained previously, such city development, to become a tourist city, will
have close relations with the increase of prostitution practices, either the
legal or covered ones.
(2) The
involvement of a woman in prostitution with all kinds and all forms of practice
in public, is closely related to the problems of educational level, labour
market, and the shape of human relations among men and women, or husband and
wife.
Therefore these
urgent problems have to be met before we begin our efforts on the so called
"prostitution abolishment". We must accompany her in seeking a way
out from her world.
(3) Prostitution
practices as mentioned above, happen in various places in Indonesia and are
related to the status and role of women with-
47
in the family and society, as we see from the
discussions with various women in this kind of practice.
There is also an
impression that many women flee to and enter the practice of prostitution as a
protest to the problem of their status which is a level below men.