Cambodia Human Rights and Solidarity Workshop

 

People's Cry and their Struggle

Wong Yock Leng

(General Secretary of Singapore SCM)

 

 

Background

Pochentong International Airport gave us a warm and humid greeting as we landed on this small airport of Cambodia on 17 October for a 6-day Human Rights & Solidarity Workshop organised by WSCF-AP and co-hosted by the newly established Cambodian SCM. Ten regional SCMs participated in this workshop which includes Thailand, Aotearoa, India, Korea, Taiwan, Singapore, Japan, Hong Kong, Myanmar, and not forgetting, the host country - Cambodia.

Peace has always been an elusive word for the Cambodians. Since the decline of the Angkor Empire (modern Cambodia's predecessor) in the 19th Century, Cambodia was always being pushed into countless rounds of political chess game, often playing the role of a mere pawn in relation to its stronger neighbours. First, it was Vietnam which absorbed the southern part of Cambodia, including the delta of Mekong River. Then came the French which set up a protectorate under the name of preserving the importance of Indo-China. When the Cold War entered this region just after 2nd World War, it was yet another round of chaotic political game as the complications created by China, Soviet Union and America became so enmeshed that each suspiciously and jealously manipulated their influence in the region. Cambodia was helplessly caught in-between this super-powers' manipulation.

In the 1960s, when the escalation between America and Vietnam rose to an all-time high, America sought to install a regime in Cambodia which favoured US policies. It then backed General Lon Nol to stage a coup d'etat, and took over the reins from Prince Norodom Sihanouk whose neutrality policy was worrying. During this time, Cambodia was wantonly used as a battleground to subdue Vietnamese communist forces there. The US government dropped tons of bombs into the countrysides and raided the whole of Cambodia relentlessly with B-52s. Not only the economy was very badly affected, scores of refugees fluxed into the city, homeless, hungry and angry.

In 1975, Cambodia visioned a new sense of peace when Pol Pot took powers over from Lon Nol. The new found peace became a mockery when Pol Pot, obsessed with xenophobia, sought to create a 'pure' Khmer race, purging all those whom he thought were against him which would mean against Cambodia, or those who were foreign-sympathetics. That started the Genocide years when nearly 2 million people were killed mercilessly. These mass killings stopped only when the Vietnamese once again invaded the country in 1979 and bowing out only 10 years later. But again, peace still could not be found as the two opposing political parties under Prince Rannaridth and Hun Sen fought continuously to gain supremacy in the already fragile parliament and further caused disruptions to the recovery process until recent years when both parties came to a compromise.

  

The Road to Recovery

The road to recovery for the Cambodians is perhaps a tough one. As our resource person for the first input for Cambodia's society, Mr. Smak Sothy - the general secretary of Kampuchea Christian Council (KCC) said that though Cambodia is almost free from bloodshed, the eminent social problem arose is the unemployment issue. Countless landmines being laid in the agricultural lands had made farming near impossible. 60% of the population is under the poverty line and many flocked to the city for a living. Earning an income becomes difficult and many people turn to social ills like robbery, kidnapping and corruption. Fire arms (about 40% of the population still possesses arms) are still a common sight as the government has difficulty to enforce stringent checks. In times of these, education to the youth is perhaps the saving grace to reduce social injustices, but the government seems to be slow in prioritising this aspect. The gap between the rich and poor is huge, and the lands owned by the rich was refused access to the poor for cultivating agriculture.

However, though steps taken by the government is slow, there is still a gradual sense of making life a better one. Development and reconstruction of roads from cities to provinces are underway, irrigation systems are being built, policies to reduce deforestation, and more private schools for a decent education are encouraged. Religion and freedom of expression is allowed although they should not be seen and felt as a malicious threat to the government. Various government plans are launched to increase salaries of government officials to reduce corruption, and also to campaign against drug-trade, arms possession, kidnapping and robberies.

 

Churches and Christianity in Cambodia

Our second input was a presentation of Cambodia's churches and Christianity by Yuak Kuntheasambo, a pastor from Khmer Presbyterian Fellowship.

Christianity enjoyed a relatively breezy period since mid of this century but soon things started to go awry when Pol Pot came into power in 1975. As it was perceived as a foreign evil, Christianity was disallowed. People were moved to the rural to cultivate lands, and education provided by the missionaries was discontinued as it was seen as an unnecessary tool in the rural. During this time, many educated Khmers were killed for they were thought to be foreign sympathetics. In 1979 when the Vietnamese gained power, Christianity was still seen in an unfavourable light and was not given much room to recover. But many secret churches were set up for those who stayed in this faith steadfastly. In 1990, the government became more relaxed and in the 1991 Paris Peace Agreement, rights to religion was granted and Christianity was then able to gain some grounds. Many foreign missionaries came once again and in 1995, the Kampuchea Christian Council was established (KCC). To date, the Baptist Church, Methodist Church, Independent Churches and the Cambodia Christian Youth Association are all affiliated to the KCC, and there are eight Bible Schools, 200 formal and home churches altogether.

However, there are some problems that many Cambodian Christians face. Firstly, the foreign missionaries who came brought along their wealth which are used to build big churches, attracting only the rich, creating a larger gap with the poor.

Moreover, these foreign missionaries introduced into Cambodia different denominational groups, which was not a common sight in the early days, and created disunity and disagreement amongst churches as a result. The foreigners also have a poor knowledge and respect of Cambodian culture and tradition and often try to inject their foreign ideas into the lives of the Cambodian Christians.

 

Exposure

We had two full days of exposure, and on the first day, we went to the Museum of Crimes and the Killing Fields to understand more on the atrocities inflicted by Pol Pot. We also went to the Documentation Centre of Cambodia which documented the Cambodian Genocide.

As we walked into the compound of the former Toul Sleng Prison where the Museum of Crimes was situated, we were greeted by trees and a light breeze. But behind this cool atmosphere, one just could not believe that the horrors of ruthless tortures actually had happened in this place 24 years ago. The obsession of Pol Pot to eliminate all suspects of 'anti-Khmer' slaughtered a total of 1.7 million people. It was in this Toul Sleng Prison that all suspects had to undergo confession trials and endless rounds of torture which methods range from hitting the body with metal rods to semi-drowning the victims, before they were sent elsewhere to be killed. We could not shake off the horrendous image caused by the pictures of tortured victims as Pol Pot had a fancy in taking their photographs before and after they were killed.

The tortured victims were then led to the "Killing Fields" in Cheoung Ek to be killed. Words could not describe our sadness when we saw the mass graves there. Out of the 129 mass graves, only 86 were identified and dug out for proper burial, the rest was perhaps un-identifiable and inaccessible. We had our morning devotion under one Bodhi Tree and offered our prayers to the people who had died with a suffering spirit.

The third place we visited was the Documentation Centre of Cambodia (DC-Cam). It was established in 1995 as a field office for the Cambodian Genocide Programme (CGP) of Yale University, funded by the U.S. Department of State. In 1997, DC-Cam became autonomous and is operated entirely by the Cambodians with financial support and guidance from scholars and experts in USA and Australia. Its three main concerns are: Documentation; Historiographical Research; and Legal Training. All these serve as resources to provide the public with a better understanding of the Pol Pot regime, and to Cambodians or others who may wish to pursue legal redress for genocide, war crimes and crimes against humanity which may have perpetrated under the regime.

So far, DC-Cam has already covered 140 out of 170 provinces to recover the facts and records. And most villagers were supportive to its work, they were ready to talk about their experiences which they witnessed or which they had gone through themselves. Many felt relieved from the years of painful silence and wanted justice to be meted out. Of course such detailed documentation is dangerous work for DC-Cam because they might inadvertently meet some people who were accomplices of the regime then. But, to ensure just documentation, DC-Cam is ready to take precautions and carry on fight for justice.

The second day of exposure brought us to the Health Rehabilitation Centre for Disabled Soldiers which provides a living community for former soldiers who became disabled during the civil war. This centre houses 164 families and has a total of 500 people, and is solely financed by the government, providing food and basic necessities.

As we walked around the community, we noticed that most of the people seemed to be walking listlessly and have nothing much to do. There is a serious lack of vocational training facilities for adults as well as children. The only vocational skill provided for adults is English and Khmer languages, and children have to attend school outside the community as there is no schooling facilities there.

We moved on to the second place which was a rural area occupied by former war refugees. These people had fled to neighbouring Thailand during the civil war and have all returned to Cambodia when the war ended. The lands in the rural area were given by the government to cultivate rice and for fish trading. However, most lands are infertile and lack comprehensive irrigation systems, thus, the villagers cannot do much rice farming. The daily average income for them is USD1.5 and they would have to source out other means if it is insufficient to support the family. For instance, one family we visited tried to have fuller meals by rearing ducks and chickens. There is both a primary and secondary school for children but many families could only afford primary education for their children.

Many of us were saddened by the places we had visited so far as the glimpse of hope seems beyond reach, and we pondered on the last place of exposure if it could hit us with another depression. However the Center of the Dove in Ang Snoul District greeted us with a pleasant sense of peace and serenity. This center is established by the Jesuits Service (JS) and has two main programmes namely the Centre for the Disabled and the Rural Development Centre for people who are either disabled by the war or who live in the poverty line respectively.

In the Centre for the Disabled, vocational skill trainings such as electricity, welding, carpentry, sculpture, mechanic, weaving and sewing. It also offers training in agriculture with emphasis on animal health and permaculture, principles of sound farm management and small businesses. The teachers are Khmer and many of them are disabled themselves. At present, there are 100 disabled men and women enrolled in this school. The fees for these lessons are fully subsidised by JS and it has a wonderful Outreach Programme whose officers go to villages and scout for people who are disabled and might be keen to learn some practical skills to enhance their sense of dignity while providing themselves with a permanent or part-time income generating possibility.

The Rural Development Centre set up programmes that could meet the real needs of villagers. Thus, instead of setting up monetary banks which may be useless in rural areas, the Center sets up Rice and Animal Banks; Water Programme; Animal Raising, Rural Health Programmes; Women in Village Development; Farmer's Solidarity Groups and Adult Literacy Programme. All these programmes help villagers to manage their own farms in a better and effective way while not overly dependent on the government's limited resources.

We were greatly heartened by the programmes and enthusiasm of these two centers and the smiles on the villagers' face gave us much warmth. Although financing the centres is an uphill task, JS' emphasis on using love as a motivating force to reconciliation, peace and justice for people who have been hurt in the war, is perhaps the strongest will to walk this journey despite whatever difficulties.

To understand a country, it will not be a full one if there is no informal exposure to the night spots. During some of the nights, many of us went to the sex-trade areas, bars and discotheques. The experience in those places could perhaps cause the wrath of many feminists. Although legally speaking, sex trades are not permissible, still they are very much alive and happen in bars, massage parlours and discotheques. In abundance and cheap rates (USD 4 for a sex-worker along the red-light district, ~USD 25 for a call-service or in higher-end bars and pubs), we dare not think of the worst situation for the women in terms of physical, mental and emotional health.

 

Sharing on Exposure

The fourth day of the Workshop brought us back to a more subdued mood as we shared our thoughts and feelings on the past few days' experiences. Unanimously, most of us were not aware of what Cambodia has been through before. Genocide, mass killings, landmines, deterioriating social values, lost spirit and wandering hope, were not what we had fathomed about Cambodia. Here, we were faced with this stark reality. Many of us felt helpless by what we saw, and could only found words like: sad, powerless, shocked, disappointment, deep pain to describe our comprehension of this society. Questions on the role of the government and importantly, the task of the Churches were hovering incessantly around our heads: What would they do, how would they start, where is the point for reconciliation in peace and justice?

 

The Landmine Issue

The Landmine issue is definitely one of the more eminent problems of Cambodia, we had the good opportunity to learn more from our next resource person, Mr. Leng Mouly - chairperson of the Cambodian Mine Action Centre (CMAC) which is one of the 3 de-mining centres in Cambodia. CMAC has the financial and technical support from UN and the international community in this task since 1992.

During the wars, Cambodia was laced with a total of 10 million mines covering primarily the rural areas. Even though all wars were over, landmines continued to take thousands of lives and maiming hundreds. Lands became useless and unable for cultivation as long as the mines are not cleared. According to current statistics, there are still 4-6 million of mines in Cambodia, covering a total area of 3000 square kilometers. The wanton spread of mines could perhaps be explained that it just take USD2 to plant a mine, but USD1000 to de-mine one! Thus far in its operation, CMAC has cleared 100 000 mines and 500 000 undisclosed bombs. Hence, the two main tasks of CMAC are : Mine Education and Mine Clearance.

Mine Education involves teaching the villagers the dangers of landmines and ways to avoid tramping on them accidentally. However, as villagers are often eager to start re-cultivating the lands, they would overlook the dangers and take the risks. Moreover, some rural areas are inaccessible by roads and transport, this complicates information to be reached. Thus far, CMAC has sent officials to as many villages as possible, educating the villagers as much as possible.

With the current number of mines and the speed of clearance, it needs 300 years for total clearance, but as Mr. Leng hoped, landmines' life expectancy is about 75 years, if Cambodia could wait this long, the road to recovery is perhaps easier.

 

Socio-Political-Economic Issues of Cambodia

We had the privilege of Mr. Klye Gillespie from the UN High Commission for Human Rights in Cambodia to give us an input on the above topic.

According to Mr. Gillespie, the most prevalent Human Rights problems are:

1)                   Impunity: child prostitution, kidnapping, robberies, murders, unlawful land confiscation, corruption among police and judiciary system, are some of the threats to security, peace and justice. Money rules in Cambodia, and this has become the means to solve social problems. The police is not trusted and increasingly, mob-violence is used by people to resolve social injustices.

2)                   Limited Press Freedom: the freedom of expression by unhappy individuals or communities is curbed.

3)                   Rampant Political Arrests: fighting between the two main political parties commonly see many intimidation and harassment toward the people and other political parties.

4)                   Trafficking: of women, men, children, into the sex-trade industry. Usually, such acts involved the high officials or the wealthy, thus many cases are unresolved.

5)                   Labour Rights Violation: usually involved the foreign companies in Cambodia. They take advantage of the poverty situation and the high demand for work, thus setting up unfair working conditions and benefits. The average factory worker earns only USD40 which is insufficient to the monthly average need of USD170.

 

Some Economic Rights problems are:

1)  Health Care: inadequately provided and expensive. There are few hospitals and many dysfunctioning problems like insufficient medicine, electricity in the wards. Only the wealthy can afford better health care, and even so, usually they would get treatment abroad. With the national budget allocating only 15-20% to health care, education and housing, and 60% to the police and military, very little could be expected for such needs.

2)  Education: in 1994-5, the two opposing political parties, out of their own egos, compete to build schools. However, the irony was there was no teachers even though there were schools! Presently, less than 5% of the population has secondary education, and 30% are illiterate. More women have less education than men (as usual). Foreign NGOs helped by providing more private schools but the government is not doing much. What most Cambodians need now is vocational training as foreign factories need skill labour, but, it is inadequately done in this aspect.

3)  Economic: there is a high percentage of malnutritioned people especially children and refugees who have returned after the wars. But there are insufficient lands to grow food because of land-mines and little development plans. Cambodia produces rice but its policy remains that the export of rice is important as a revenue, hence, there is insufficient rice for its own people and rice has to be imported again, to feed the people!

Cambodia receives a yearly grant of USD500 million in foreign aid to help revive the country, and that makes up to more than USD5 billion given over the last 5 years. However, it seems that Cambodia has not been able to produce a decent report on re-building the nation, risking the pulling out of foreign aids inadvertently if it still remain in this status quo. But again, the hovering question is: Will it deteriorate further and cause willful lawlessness? This is a conflicting dilemma.

 

Dialogue -with Cambodia SCM

The Cambodian SCM was just established 3 months ago, and at present it has about 10 members. Our exchange with them shed some realisations on the difficulty of school life and social awareness in Cambodia. First of all, Cambodian youths are not taught of its history and most of them do not have a comprehensive knowledge of the past events. Many of them inherited this society with the knowledge that their privilege to receive an education is utmost important to make a decent living in future, and not falling into the poverty line. Thus, they tend to prioritise their rights to their own education before anything else.

When we asked the youths on their assessment to Cambodia's social situation, and the word used was: helplessness. Many of them do not know where to start in the help to alleviate the overwhelming social problems. Moreover, many youth associations defer in the starting-point opinions and inevitably engage in endless arguments among themselves. As it is to be seen, it would be an uphill task for SCM Cambodia as we make plans in the next session, working together to see what can be helped and done for this society.

 

Action Plan

The 3 guiding principles and the consequent recommendations are:

1)       Recommendations to SCM-Cambodia

a)       As SCM-Cambodia is a relatively new movement, it needs a lot of consolidation to keep it alive with the existing students. Thus, they have to identify their focus and vision. Following that, regular small group discussions on social issues are important. A small scale internal exposure programme for the Cambodian students is a good method to let them learn and feel for its society.

b)       While students in Cambodia are not taught of its history, it is an important that SCM-Cambodia take up this task. The study of Cambodia history, its past wars, present economic and social situation. The education on the Ecumenical spirit in Christianity should also be included.

c)       SCM-Cambodia could apply for internship or volunteer with the NGOs in the country to get a better knowledge on organising work.

 

2)       What can we do in our respective movements?

a)       Exchange and Internship programmes between movements could be a possibility so that SCM-Cambodia could use the experience to reflect on their own society. However, both the movement and intern should have the committment to learn and grow together from each other's experience.

b)      Movements could exchange information using the internet and could render assistance in setting up web pages for this method of communication.

 

3)       Recommendations to sub-regional, regional and international level such as WSCF-AP and WSCF-IRO.

a)       Students with potential leadership could be sent to WSCF-AP as an understudy to the work of the regional office. While WSCF-AP could also send 1-2 persons to train the staff of SCM-Cambodia.

b)       Financial support to be given by WSCF or WSCF-AP when it is appropriate and needed.

 

Goodbye Cambodia

It was raining as we bade goodbye to our Cambodian friends. As the van approached Pochentong Airport, there was a mixed feeling of leaving this place. In only a short 6-day stay, there are so much realisation and new knowledge of this country. As we looked out of the van's windows, we could see the bustling morning market, the people going about their morning routines. But, this was just what we saw at the moment, we could not help but pondered of their future which is so vulnerable to the existing social willfulness. At this point in time, we could only offer a small prayer in our hearts.

Main Page