Report on the WSCF-AP Human Rights and Solidarity Workshop 2000

 

“Militarization and Human Rights Violations in Asia Pacific”

 

 

Introduction

  The Militarism and the practice of Militarization confront most of countries in Asia Pacific region. As a result of it, military abuses, human rights violation, increased military budget and expenditures, threatening of peoples lives, displacement from livelihood, suppression and flagrant denial of justice and freedom to people is notoriously standing out all over the region.

    Given the ardent need to intensify our respond, and to encourage the SCMs(Student Christian Movements) on the national level to extend further efforts in addressing  the issues related to militarization and human rights violation, the World Student Christian Federation-Asia Pacific Region (WSCF-AP) initiated the Human Rights and Solidarity Workshop(HRSW). The theme was “ Militarization and Human Rights Violation in Asia Pacific”.   This workshop was organized in Jakarta, Indonesia last September 17-23, 2000 and was participated by SCM members coming from 11 countries in Asia Pacific.  A total of 24 participants were present in the activity.   Thirteen  (13) of whom are delegates from Indonesia, Australia, Burma, Cambodia, Thailand, Philippines, Sri Lanka, India, Korea, Taiwan and Hong Kong; 2 resource speakers, the Indonesian host committee and 2 WSCF-AP staff members.

 

The Objectives of the Workshop are as follows:

To enable the selected number of student leaders of SCM understand the bitter reality of militarism and militarization, its effects and relevance to the students.

To enable the participants to articulate the situation of the people and the victims affected by militarization.

To provide the participants the opportunity to witness the situation of the victims affected (e.g. victims of torture, illegal detention, disappearances, harassment, displaced communities, etc.)

To provide the participants the skills in conducting fact finding or investigative mission, solidarity activity to specific areas of concerns.

To enable the participants to identify critical aspects of possible solidarity networking, investigative mission, and fact finding mission.

To encourage the participants to organize groups in the campus to support the victims of militarization.

To encourage member movements to initiate solidarity activity in the national level in order to response to the human rights violation caused by militarization.

To facilitate the internship for exchange and joint solidarity actions between different SCMs.

 

General Summary of the Workshop

  Prior to the actual workshop, the participants from respective countries were asked to prepare a written document on the result of their integration, research and interviews conducted in their countries with the victims, communities, organizations concerned and affected by Militarization and Human Rights violation. These paper were then used during the country reports included as part of the workshop.

The actual activity was started by an opening worship and reflection led by Rev. Richard Daulay, Associate General Secretary of the Indonesian National Council of Churches (PGI).  Two inputs were provided for the participants before and after the exposure trip.  A bible study and reflections was also done as part of the activity.  Before the workshop ended, all the participants were able to come up with concrete plan of action in the local, national, regional, and international levels.

 

Input Discussion Summary

  Mr. Liberato Bautista, an SCM senior friend from the Philippines provided the first lecture discussion. Mr. Bautista works with the Global Board of Church and Society of the United Methodist Church in the United Nation office in New York as Assistant Secretary General.   The discussion focussed on two parts.  The first dealt with the theory and phenomena of militarism and how governments have practiced Militarization.  It was pointed out that militarism as a concept and militarization as its practice assaulted human values that people held for survival.  He emphasized, “militarism and militarization  not only dis-empowers the human agency but also disables the moral agency so that it will take over all power and principle - militarism promotes a culture of death”.   It was also strongly pointed out that both militarism and militarization were inherently violent of human rights as it affronted human dignity and negated the wholeness of humanity.   During the open forum, it came out that “as the governance of militaristic regimes proceed human rights violation much as it frustrates the just and peaceful governance”.  As a concrete example was the process how the colonial wars of attrition had not only decimated the number of people but also inhabited the minds and hearts of those who survived.

  On the second part of Mr. Bautista’s discussion, he underlined the Geo-Political, Geo-Economics and Geo-Cultural implications to people’s lives since Militarism had assaulted people in all directions in different forms justified as National Security Doctrine. According to him, “the Geo-political and Geo-economic aspects of militarization tends to control the distribution, allocation, production of specific resources that in turn displaces people and violates their rights as human and destroys their source of livelihood”.  He pointed out, “the geo-cultural implications on the other hand tends to control the geo-graphic influences leading to cultural subjugation which affects the mentality and penetrates peoples minds to justify its “irrelevance”. 

  The last part of the discussion concentrated on how people countered militarism by encouraging people, to understand militarism as a concept and frustrate militarization: “By encouraging people, victims and non-victims learn each other from the pat experiences. By uniting people’s ranks, it will muster the sophistication needed to fight and or counter the sophistication of the forces of military”. 

 

            Input on Indonesian Militarization and Human Rights Situation

  The 2nd major input discussion was provided by Mr. Asmara Nababan, who is also a senior friend from Indonesia SCM (GMKI).  He is currently the Secretary General of the Indonesian National Commission on Human Rights.  Mr. Nababan outlined the interesting discussion, which focussed on the current human rights situation in Indonesia.  He pointed out many changes since Suharto step down as president. One of the changes is that the NGOs, the victims and their families are taking the initiatives in asserting and fighting for respect, recognition of people’s rights, and demanding justice and compensation to the victims and families greatly affected by military atrocities.  He asserted, “even though Indonesia held a democratic election in 1999, the military still holds a strong influence over the civilian government and at the same time conservative blocks and supporters of Suharto still clings in the entire government”.

Mr. Ababan has reiterated that while Indonesia is still undergoing transition, the most hoped justice for the victims may or may not still be assured: “The trials for the culprits in the military atrocities such as massacres, extra-judicial executions, torture, rape and all other injustices are still uncertain. While there is strong clamor to put Suharto and his cohorts in court, the people’s prerogative to generate more local and international efforts is needed”.  At the same time, he told, “Indonesian people should demand the civilian government to raise the level of a more positive concern to the victims and families”.

The issue of East Timor and Papua was also tackled in the discussion.  It was pointed out that the Indonesian government and the military should take into consideration the clamor of the people in East Timor for justice and complete independence.  Though there has been an international recognition of independence and the UN has stepped-in to the matter, the military and government is still making efforts to support the militias and pro-integration groups, causing a series of human rights violations

Nonetheless, the participants seemed to agree, “what the East Timor needed the most is financial, material, political and economic support to build and establish an independent East Timor State”.

 

            Exposure

  The exposure was divided in two parts.  In the first half, all the participants went together to visit different organizations formed by the families and victims of torture, arbitrary arrests, falsely accused and dis-appearances during the Suharto military regime.  The victims told the participants that around two million people between 1965-1968 who were sympathetic to the Sukarno’s government were killed, imprisoned, tortured and disappeared.  The organizations are demanding justice for the missing family members and compensation to the victims and families.

On the 2nd half  of the exposure, participants were divided in two groups. The first group visited several NGOs: i)East Timor Solidarity Movement  ii)the Papua Student Solidarity iii)the “Kontras” which is handling the cases of involuntary disappearances and tortures.  The other exposure group went to visit Labor groups.  Particularly, the participants met one labor union activist who had been imprisoned for more than 3 years during the Suharto government, and discussed how the military regime of Suharto oppressed the just economic demands of Indonesian workers.  Like the rest of the other NGOs and Indonesian people, they have been subjected to harsh military persecution and government repression.  Aside from demanding for justice for the human rights violations committed against them by the Suharto regime, they have been also  clamoring for economic and political justice such as decent jobs, humane working and living condition in the workplaces.

 

            National Reports

  Each participant was asked to share and report their respective country situation related to militarization and human rights violation. The syntheses of the reports are as follows:

o        Most governments in Asia exercise authoritarian rule.

o        Governments are strongly influenced or dominated by the military.

o        Human rights violation committed by military is affecting not only  the livelihood of people but also  the environment – it is a holistic violation against humanity and God’s creation 

o        The effects of military atrocities is still affecting the victims and their families.

o        There is a large budget allocated to military compared to other social services.

o        Militarism is being used by the government to greatly influence culture, economic and politics.

o        Militarization is being used as instrument to serve the interests of those in power in the government and manipulate the demands of the people.

o        Militarism and Militarization is used to give way for MNC &TNC and the unjust economic trends motivated by globalization and capitalism.

o        There are efforts being done among the ranks of the SCMs and other NGO’s who are struggling against militarization and fighting for justice to the victims.

o        Women and Children have been and still affected by long term suffering caused by militarization

o        Militarism is promoting a culture of Death/ Killing.

o        United States controls a strong military influence and dominance in Asia Pacific region that affects the government policy and the peoples’ lives.

o        Military is serving as instrument to suppress and oppress people in assuring the globalization scheme

 

            Bible Reflection

Rev. Shin Seung Min, the WSCF Regional Secretary facilitated the bible reflection. Participants were divided into groups and asked to reflect on the bible text “Mathew 20:1-16”.  After each group presented their respective reflections, Rev. Shin reiterated three major interpretations. He outlined the traditional, moderate, and radical interpretations on the said text.

 

            Action Plan

  The participants were divided into sub-regional groups, and asked to make appropriate action plans on the national, regional, and international level. The following is the synthesis of the action plans of all the groups:

 

            Local and National Level

o        Launch continuous discussion and education work among SCM members and other student groups in the universities and  the churches

o        Link-up and work with other NGOs and student groups, particularly with those NGOs who work for women and children victims of militarization

o        Bible studies and reflections

o        Release statements; position papers to the media, the embassies, and to the government

o        Have worship using traditional symbols to remind the militarization and the victims

o        Develop a homepage for this issue

o        Conduct exposure  to areas affected by militarization

o        Release statements and posters in the universities, communities and churches

o        Recruit volunteers for advocacy

o        Regular integration to areas affected by militarization

 

            Regional Level

o        Sign petition to government particularly for Burma and East Timor Network

o        Organize a simultaneous solidarity actions among SCMs in front of the embassies whose countries violate human rights

o        Strengthen exchange program among national movements on the regional and sub-regional level

o        Release the issue of militarization in the Praxis

o        Promote Peoples Forum to be organized by SCM India, Sri Lanka and Pakistan in order to discuss war and conflict in these three countries

o        Networking with other anti-militarization student bodies

o        Raise fund for the victims by the militarization

o        Organize the Universal Day of Prayers for Women and Children victims of militarization and human rights violation(SCM Australian and Philippines will write paper on this)

 

            International Level

o        Establish Links with other SCM in other regions such as Africa and Latin-America that experience the same problems of militarization, and work out a possible solidarity cooperation.

o        Submit petition to the UN pertaining to East Timor, Papua, and Burma and other countries.

o        Compile workshop results and minutes and send to the SCMs who were not able to attend the workshop (Japan, Bangladesh, New Zealand and Pakistan)

o        Conduct research and release position paper to the International networks on the effects of “globalization” and how military is being used as instrument of economic repression.

 

Main Page